Choose Your Wonder

Small-Batch Cookies & Handcrafted Sweets

Thick bakery-style cookies, nostalgic oatmeal cream pies, brownies, cake pops & seasonal sweets - handcrafted in Frostburg, Maryland

Shop Our Sweets Our Story

Subscriber Access

Get first access to drops, pre-orders, and announcements

Enter your email to unlock the full experience with Wonder & Whisk Bakehouse — track orders, get notifications, and more.

Benefits:

Track orders
Live chat with Wonder & Whisk Bakehouse
Customize notifications
Benefit from loyalty rewards

Featured Creations

Discover our most beloved items, each crafted with passion and the finest ingredients

Featured

Fudgy Wonder

Rich, decadent, and unapologetically fudgy. ✨️ Made with premium Dutch process cocoa and dark chocolate for a deep, intense chocolate flavor, with that irresistible crackly top and melt-in-your-mouth center. One bite and you'll understand why we call it a Wonder.

$4.00 - $42.004 options

View All Products

Our Story

What started as a passion for baking in our home kitchen has grown into a beloved local business. We're committed to bringing you the same quality and care that we put into every item we make for our own family.

Read Our Full Story